Skip to main content
Charitable

QCD vs Roth Conversion Planner (RMD + IRMAA)

Model baseline MAGI, RMD, QCD, and Roth conversions to estimate conversion room before an IRMAA threshold and build a sequencing playbook.

Why This Tool Exists

In retirement planning, sequence is often the strategy. Not because sequence changes the math, but because it changes what is possible.

This planner helps you map QCD and Roth conversion decisions against an IRMAA guardrail using numbers you can actually estimate.

Execution note: Run the tool, then write down your assumptions and keep the receipts and logs as you go. The strategy that wins on paper only matters if your process holds up in the real world.

QCD + Conversion Room Planner

Estimate taxable RMD after QCD and conversion room inside an IRMAA guardrail you enter.

Enter the next threshold you want to avoid (year + filing status dependent).
QCD can reduce taxable distribution income depending on mechanics.
Taxable RMD (after QCD)
$0
Planning estimate
Conversion room (guardrail)
$0
After buffer
Projected MAGI (with conversion)
$0
Inside
Scenario QCD Conversion Projected MAGI Result
Practical rule: decide your guardrail early, then execute monthly. The "right" sequence is the one you can actually follow without surprises.

Sequencing Playbook (What You Are Really Deciding)

QCDs can reduce income from required distributions and create more room for conversions.

Roth conversions can raise MAGI and push you into IRMAA brackets if you do not watch headroom.

The point is to build a plan that fits your reality: RMD needs, donation intent, and bracket control.

Inputs That Matter Most

Baseline MAGI (before RMD/QCD/conversions).

RMD amount and planned QCD amount (QCD is limited by RMD mechanics).

The IRMAA threshold you want to treat as a guardrail, plus your buffer.

Execution Notes

Do not wait until December to discover you have no headroom.

If you are close to the line, build a buffer and consider using withholding to smooth surprises.

Store the output as part of your year folder so you can explain decisions later.

Documentation Checklist (Keep It Defensible)

  • Create a one-page objective memo before you execute (what outcome you are trying to buy).
  • Store your assumptions and calculations in a dated PDF (no year-end reconstructions).
  • Keep evidence in the same folder structure every month (receipts, logs, approvals).
  • Ask your CPA what would make this easy to sign off on, then build that packet.

Frequently Asked Questions

Often the core math is similar, but sequence changes constraints and guardrails. The practical win is executing a plan without accidental bracket crossings.

It can, depending on your facts. This tool estimates conversion room by subtracting taxable RMD (after QCD) from your IRMAA headroom.

You only need the guardrail you care about. Enter the next threshold and a buffer so the plan stays conservative.

Turn The Tool Into An Execution Plan

The people who win are not the ones who find a strategy. They are the ones who build a monthly system, keep receipts and logs, and hand their CPA a clean packet.

Join the 3-Day Wealth Challenge

Educational content only. Results vary based on your facts. Always consult a qualified tax professional before making decisions.