Is 1% always enough?+
No. It is a starting heuristic, and it scales with value rather than with what actually breaks. Track your real spending for two years and replace the guess with your own number.
Should the reserve be based on value or on square footage?+
Both are approximations. A per-square-foot figure often tracks reality better, because a roof costs what it costs regardless of the neighbourhood. Use whichever produces the more conservative number.
Does this cover renovations?+
No. This is upkeep: repairs, servicing, and replacing things that wear out. Renovations are discretionary projects and belong in the renovation contingency budget calculator.
Are these numbers financial advice?+
No. They are educational estimates based on the inputs and assumptions on this page. Confirm important decisions with a qualified professional and your own documents.